Review: Her Rogue Alpha by Paige Tyler


Her Rogue AlphaHer Rogue Alpha
Paige Tyler
Gikany and Una
Rating: DNF / C

What We’re Talking About:

This is an odd review to write since only Una finished the book, but we do that we were disappointed with Layla and Jayson’s story.

Una finished the novel, but found herself feeling let down.  The connection between Layla and Jayson was forged early in the series.  Their story is one we have waited for: a shifter who just joined the X-Ops and her wounded soldier.  However, Jayson is emotionally abusive.  The abuse is substantial enough to make us feel that there should possibly be trigger warnings for this book.  In the end he does apologize for being selfishly brooding in his disability, but it was long overdue.  He was brash and reckless in the beginning, and Layla accepted that all the pain he caused her was okay because he loves her.  Their reunion in a battlefield was odd and seemed untimely.  The plot of Jayson’s mission was convoluted and far-fetched – especially his abilities.  At the end of the novel, there is a revelation about Jayson that Layla reads and then destroys – without the reader being privy to it.  This carrot dangling was infuriating to Una.  Since this part of the story was told from Layla’s perspective, we should have been privy to the message.  It would have been preferable to have her destroy the note without looking.

The plot that kept Una reading was regarding a thief.  This plot line is tied to the search for the enemy within the X-Ops.  Una found this storyline fascinating and intriguing.  And knowing it is not the end of seeing the thief, we hope to see her in a future novel.

Gikany did not finish this novel.  The emotional abuse that begins between Layla and Jayson was too much.  By the 25% mark, the urge to have Layla punch Jayson and leave him was too great for Gikany.  She felt that there was no way he could redeem himself, and he just didn’t deserve her love.  Gikany could not stand to read anymore.

Although we do agree that this novel did not go altogether well, Una was able to finish it.  Both Gikany and Una were disappointed in this long awaited story.  Una will read the next novel in the series but Gikany will not.

Una’s Rating:  C, Finished It – Liked some, didn’t like some
Gikany’s Rating:  DNF – Did Not Finish


About the Book:


Former Special Forces Lieutenant Jayson Harmon can’t believe that his war scars don’t matter to beautiful feline shifter Layla Halliwell. Why would she saddle herself with a broken man?

But Layla knows that Jayson is a hero to the core, and that only she can heal his wounded soul. So when Jayson is deployed on another deadly mission, no way is Layla staying behind…

Release Date: September 6, 2016
X-Ops #5
Paranormal Romance/Military
Paperback (320 pages), e-book
Book Source: Publisher/NetGalley

Purchase Info:

Reviews in the Series:
Her Perfect Mate by Paige Tyler (X-Ops #1)
Her Lone Wolf by Paige Tyler (X-Ops #2)
Her Wild Hero by Paige Tyler (X-Ops #3)
Her Fierce Warrior by Paige Tyler (X-Ops #4)

  • Yikes, not that awesome then

    • UnaReads

      A bit of a let down, yes.

  • Bummer 🙁 this is a series I’ve been on the fence about trying… You may have just pushed me off lol great review

    • UnaReads

      The previous books were good but this one wasn’t like the others. I’m hoping this one is just a fluke.

  • That stinks. I’d heard very good things about it. I’ve only read in her other series and like it but maybe holding off on this series for now.

Powered by WordPress | Designed by Elegant Themes